Computer World just ran an article asking this very question — and responding with an emphatic yea. I am less convinced, although I am an avid user myself.
Also, just so everyone’s aware, I’m comparing Ubuntu to Windows directly. Where Macs are concerned, I advocate them for anyone who cares to use one and who can afford it — neither of which applies to me particularly, although I’m awfully tempted to get a Macbook on account of music production software running so much better on Macs.
Anyhow, there are many types of users who can benefit from installing Ubuntu:
The Clueless
Group number 1 is the basic-to-clueless computer-user. A child, your grandma, anyone that’s going to be floundering a little bit regardless of their OS. This comes with the caveat that you, or someone above this tier of computer literacy, install the system for them.
For someone brand new to it, Ubuntu may actually be easier than Windows. The graphical repository system and “Add Programs” menu, the latter of which is basically a dumbed-down version of the former, make it fairly easy to add and remove software. This is certainly easier than finding the right program online, downloading the .exe, and then going through the setup pages.
These are also the folks who are likely to click on a link to install FREE! new smileys, in which case they will enjoy the benefits of having some user/root separation, and not ending up bogged down with malware.
The Cheap
Let me start by saying that this is my group. It’s not that I’m too cheap to buy Vista, it’s that I’m too cheap to to buy a computer that will run Vista happily. I love the fact the Ubuntu runs on any machine made in the last 5 years or so. Often, older is even better, since the drivers have already been written. Switch to Xubuntu and you can go even further back. After that you get into even more specialized small-distribution territory - a land where even I am not cash-poor enough to venture.
Oh yeah, and you might as well lump Grandma in here, too. She’ll prefer having a computer that will be good for a decade without changing up the hardware.
The Nerdier-than-thou
Alright, this is sort of me too. I’m an advanced computer user, but somehow I couldn’t consider myself such without learning Linux. I’m happy to say it’s been a solid year, and I’ve emerged a convert. Us too-computer-savvy nerd types, who can overcome the technical problems associated with switching, and think Beryl is totally sweet, are in clear Linux territory. Not much needs to be said of us.
Who SHOULDN’T use Linux
The vast majority of computer users, however, are the third type: the kind who have been using Windows for years without caring what’s going under the hood, and are happy paying Norton to keep their computer safe, and Valve to provide them with games. There’s no reason for my dad, for instance, to start using Linux, except possibly so I can set the root password to something he doesn’t know so he won’t call me up to help him fix the wireless internet because he suddenly got on some weird security kick and installed a bunch of software that proceeded to mess everything up.
Maybe “shouldn’t” is the wrong word. “Won’t” might be better. If Windows is working perfectly well thank-you-very-much, they’ll be hard to convince, especially when you tell them that, no, Word won’t run on Ubuntu. OpenOffice.org will, and indeed has a lot going for it, but you might as well save your protestations, because it’s just not the same.
ANYHOW
I love Ubuntu. I use it at work, with Beryl and all those delights, and I make my Vista-using boss jealous. I’m so used to GIMP and Inkscape that I can’t even use Photoshop or Illustrator. I enjoy having the freedom to install whatever package I want without thinking about it, or to open a command-line to copy a bunch of files because it’s faster, or to watch my windows burn down when I close them. But for most of the populous, switching just isn’t worth it. The solution is to get Ubuntu for your kids and grandma, so that in ten or twenty years you’ll have a bunch of Linux users for whom switching to Windows just isn’t worth the effort.
Fuel another post